Osmund Agbo: Nigerian courts as political tools, not independent arbiters

Osmund Agbo: Nigerian courts as political tools, not independent arbiters

T
Triple T in Stories • November 7, 2026, 10:29 am
Gist Image

In a sharp analysis for Premium Times, Osmund Agbo argues that Nigeria's judiciary functions less as an independent arbiter than as a theater where powerful interests settle political scores. He traces this pattern through two parallel cases separated by a decade.

In December 2014, Enugu PDP held two rival governorship primaries: Senator Ayogu Eze won at Filbon Hotel with 526 votes using delegates from November 1 ward congresses, while Hon. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi won at Nnamdi Azikiwe Stadium with 933 votes via a different delegate list. A Federal High Court injunction by Justice Adeniyi Ademola had restrained the party from accepting any list other than Eze's. Yet after a three-year legal battle reaching the Supreme Court (judgment July 6, 2018), Eze's challenge was dismissed and Ugwuanyi retained the ticket. Agbo notes persistent but unsubstantiated allegations that the late Justice Centus Nweze—later a Supreme Court justice—used connections to influence the outcome in Ugwuanyi's favor.

Fast forward to October 29, 2026: Federal High Court Justice Obiora Egwuatu nullified Governor Hope Uzodimma's emergence as APC candidate for Imo West Senatorial District, declared former Governor Rochas Okorocha the lawful primary winner, and ordered INEC to recognize him. The judge cited contradictory documents from Uzodimma's camp—some claiming Option A4, others consensus, others direct primary—and the party's failure to provide Okorocha nomination forms despite requests.

Agbo draws the parallel: both Ugwuanyi and Uzodimma were likely more popular than their rivals, but both emerged through contested processes. The difference? Ugwuanyi allegedly had a "judicial godfather" in Nweze; Uzodimma may have lost his judicial protection. Agbo's conclusion is unsparing: "When the political gods decide that a particular individual must go, legal arguments can suddenly acquire an urgency and significance that nobody seemed to notice before." Uzodimma can still appeal to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, but Agbo warns: "Those who have benefited from the extraordinary power of judicial interpretation must learn to live with its consequences, even when the ruling goes against them."

The court giveth, and the court taketh away. The question for every Nigerian politician relying on judicial intervention: who is your Centus Nweze now?


SOURCE: https://www.premiumtimesng.com/opinion/923335-hope-versus-rochas-the-court-giveth-and-the-court-taketh-away-by-osmund-agbo.html


Replies (0)

Post a Reply